Click here to purchase photos
Our Opinion
10 months ago | 2514 views | 1 1 comments | 20 20 recommendations | email to a friend | print
At last week’s city council meeting, several residents who live in neighborhoods near the Smithfield Plant approached the Middlesboro City Council with a request in a respectful, business-like manner. They were asking the council members, their elected representatives, for help.

“We’re asking for the council to work with Cumberland Gap Provision to make people more aware of the dangers of this liquid when it does leak. We’re asking for some kind of warning device so the people in the neighborhood can know when leaks occur so we know how to ... evacuate when it does take place,” said Middlesboro resident David Mike at the meeting.

But their request was met with dead silence. Not a word was spoken and the mayor immediately called on the next citizen who wanted to speak at the meeting. Council then adjourned. It’s truly baffling that the mayor and council members chose not to say anything. Even if Mike, Tracy Barnett, and the other citizens had not addressed the council about the issue, shouldn’t the council or mayor at least have made some statement regarding the anhydrous ammonia spill that wiped out all of the city’s fish? Why were the city council and mayor in such a hurry to adjourn the meeting that they couldn’t at least issue a statement?

One can only wonder why, because at past council meetings, these same elected officials have not failed to respond when addressed by one of their constituents.

These residents were not asking that the Smithfield Plant be closed and run out of town. In fact, in his statement to council Mike said that Smithfield is a benefit to the community, and we agree.

The council was simply being asked to work with the company and all involved agencies to come up with a plan to help prevent further spills, and that if it should happen again that some system be set in place to notify all residents in the effected neighborhood. A perfectly reasonable request given in a clear, concise, respectful manner.

So what could be their possible reason for ignoring asuch a sensible request from the people during an open council meeting. Could it be they are afraid that by doing their jobs to protect the citizens of Middlesboro they would offend the folks at Smithfield?

As it has now been reported, some council members approached Mike and the other residents and offer their support, but only after the meeting had adjourned. And the city is indeed addressing the matter. But we are still left with the question, why only after the meeting had been adjourned and therefore off the record? This was not a controversial request.

The safety of Middlesboro’s citizens is in question. And should anhydrous ammonia spill from the plant again, or any other emergency, lives could be at stake should the city not be properly equipped or prepared.

The mayor and council members are the elected representatives of all the citizens of Middlesboro. They are our voice and they have been entrusted with our safety and the well-being of our community. We should expect nothing less.

In our opinion, however, that ball was dropped at the September 15 council meeting. What do you think?
comments (1)
« thackerl wrote on Wednesday, Dec 16 at 07:38 PM »
Well, it's been two months with no reader response (to my knowledge) to the above editorial by the newspaper. The last line was a question: What do you think? Though most assuredly there was conversation about that meeting, and others since, a lack of follow up comments by citizens via this very convenient route provided by the paper, sums things up with much clarity: not enough people care that much to take time out for expressing their opinions. There hasn't been drastically needed change within the elected and appointed leadership for the same reason. Our consistently low local voter turn out tells us the same thing. When enough of an outcry equates to REAL citizen voice, there will be change. When enough people have had enough, through personal impact, there will be change. I'm afraid things will get terribly worse before that combined voice grows and finds an organized route for change. When slogans like "can you really afford change??" (with two question marks, I might add) becomes an effective means of winning an election, it's obvious that both apathy and non-political distraction has silenced the all important common voice. There is such a fear of council meetings become the "old circus" that five minute meetings have resulted. When council meetings are rendered useless in the eyes of the citizens due to their lacking work, it should be no surpise when people take their concerns elsewhere (direct calls to city hall, to individual members). The worse thing that can happen is citizens coming to the conclusion - right or wrong - that "it won't do any good" to express my opinion. Middlesboro is on the verge of improvements, things to be proud of. But until more people get involved with getting things done outside of the government giving its nod of approval, it will be a slow process. Rather than bypassing the leaderships availability, as so many do, we must take our ideas to local organizations that can then go to our leadership and say, These are our plans and this is what we need you to do as leadership.
report abuse...

Express yourself:
We're glad to give you a forum to air your point of view on issues important to this community. We just ask that you keep things civil. Leave out the personal attacks. Do not use offensive language, ethnic or racial slurs, or assail anyone's personal or religious beliefs. For anyone who can't be civil, we reserve the right to remove your material. We also reserve the right to ban users who violate our visitor's agreement.
Weather
Sponsored By:

Lottery
Sponsored By:

Stocks
Sponsored By:

featured businesses
Gasoline Prices
Sponsored By:

Recipes
Sponsored By: